In a year marked by economic challenges, the world’s largest fast-food chain has found itself at the center of growing criticism. Despite claiming that inflationary pressures have forced price increases, the soaring profits that McDonald’s has enjoyed were driven by strategic price hikes.
The apparent exploitation of inflation has led to an exodus of price-conscious consumers, many of whom are now turning to sit-down dining establishments and competitor fast-food chains for better value.
THE INFLATION EXCUSE
Inflation has undoubtedly been a significant issue worldwide in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic and Russia’s unprovoked invasion of Ukraine, impacting everything from raw materials to labor costs. Like many companies, McDonald’s initially framed its rising menu prices as a necessary response to those economic pressures. According to public statements from the company, higher costs for beef, potatoes, and other staples were driving the need for price adjustments.
However, while some price increases may have been warranted, McDonald’s profit margins tell a different story. In its 2024 quarterly earnings reports, the fast-food giant earned record-breaking profits.
The growth was not attributed to increased customer traffic but rather to the higher prices charged per transaction. Critics argue that McDonald’s used inflation as a convenient scapegoat to justify price gouging far beyond what was necessary to cover increased costs.
Financial analysts point to McDonald’s gross profit margins, which have ballooned in recent quarters. The fast food giant is accused of leveraging the public acceptance of inflation as an excuse to maximize profits, knowing that customers were expecting prices to rise and then taking full advantage of that expectation.
THE PRICE SHOCK
For customers, the impact has been palpable. What was once considered a hallmark of affordability — a quick and cheap meal — has become a noticeably more expensive option. The price of a Big Mac meal has reportedly jumped by as much as 20% in some markets compared to 2023. In urban areas, where operating costs are already higher, consumers have reported paying upwards of $12 for a combo meal, a price point that encroaches on sit-down dining territory.
Many former McDonald’s regulars now see the chain as less of a value leader and more of a symbol of corporate greed. Social media platforms have been flooded with posts comparing McDonald’s prices to those of competitors, with many users expressing shock at how little value they feel they are getting for their money.
COMPETITORS BENEFIT FROM THE EXODUS
While McDonald’s has enjoyed increased revenues, its strategy may be backfiring in terms of customer loyalty. Other fast-food chains, including Wendy’s, Burger King, and Taco Bell, have been quick to capitalize on the growing perception that McDonald’s is no longer affordable.
Wendy’s, for instance, has doubled down on its “4 for $4” and “Biggie Bag” deals, which offer customers a full meal at a fraction of McDonald’s prices. Similarly, Taco Bell has expanded its value menu, introducing options that appeal to budget-conscious diners. Even Burger King, often seen as McDonald’s closest competitor, has emphasized its “$6 Your Way” meal deal, a stark contrast to McDonald’s higher price points.
Interestingly, sit-down restaurants have also seen an influx of former McDonald’s customers. Chains like Denny’s, IHOP, and even casual dining establishments like Applebee’s and Chili’s are increasingly being chosen by consumers who feel they get more for their money. With meal deals, happy hour discounts, and larger portions, these sit-down options are drawing families and individuals who might previously have opted for fast food.
THE GROWING BACKLASH
The backlash against McDonald’s pricing strategy has not gone unnoticed. Consumer advocacy groups and watchdog organizations have called out the company for what they describe as price gouging under the guise of inflation.
Social media campaigns criticizing McDonald’s have gained traction, with hashtags like #McGreed and #InflationExcuse trending on platforms like X and TikTok. Some former customers have even urged others to seek out alternative dining options.
TRUMP’S MCDONALD’S STUNT
During the 2024 presidential campaign, McDonald’s allowed candidate Donald Trump to use a franchised location to stage for a political stunt. Trump pretended to flip burgers and take orders at a closed store, with staged customers providing a photo opportunity so he could push the false narrative of being a man of the people.
The action came in response to criticism that he had never worked at a fast food place in his life. The visuals were compared to when presidential nominee Michael Dukakis rode around in a battle tank for a political ad, having never served in the military.
McDonald’s — a symbol of everyday America — was reduced to a prop in a play aimed at solidifying Trump’s narrative that he alone represents “real America.” The fast food chain allowed its supposedly neutral space for families to participate in a polarizing political campaign. Critics saw Trump’s act as a hollow performance that cheapened the genuine struggles of those who work for minimum wage, and a default endorsement of his campaign.
MCDONALD’S E. COLI SCANDAL
Between September 12 and October 21, McDonald’s also faced a serious E. coli poisoning outbreak among customers in 14 states. Federal health officials found that at least 104 people were sickened, with 34 hospitalized, from poisoned food tied to onions served on McDonald’s Quarter Pounder hamburgers.
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said that one person had also died in Colorado and four people had developed a potentially life-threatening kidney disease complication.
At least 30 cases were reported in Colorado, followed by 19 in Montana, 13 in Nebraska, 10 in New Mexico, eight in Missouri and Utah, six in Wyoming, three in Kansas, two in Michigan and one each in Iowa, North Carolina, Oregon, Washington, and Wisconsin.
Quarter Pounders were removed from menus in several states during the early days of the outbreak. The type of bacteria implicated in the outbreak causes about 74,000 infections in the U.S. annually, leading to more than 2,000 hospitalizations and 61 deaths each year.
Symptoms occur quickly, within a day or two of eating contaminated food, and typically include fever, vomiting, diarrhea or bloody diarrhea, and signs of dehydration — little or no urination, increased thirst, and dizziness. The infection can cause a type of serious kidney injury, especially in kids younger than 5. E. coli poisoning in young children requires immediate medical attention.
A QUESTION OF LONG-TERM IMPACT
While the company’s profits did look strong in the short term, the loss of customer trust and loyalty over prices and politics could have lasting consequences. Recent surveys suggest that McDonald’s customer satisfaction scores have dipped in 2024, with many respondents citing high prices as their primary concern. The decline in customer sentiment could spell trouble for the chain, particularly as competitors continue to position themselves as more affordable alternatives.
McDonald’s pricing controversy is also emblematic of a broader trend in corporate America. Across industries, companies have been accused of using inflation as a cover for profit-driven price increases, a practice sometimes referred to as “greedflation.” While the strategies may boost bottom lines, they also risk eroding public trust and exacerbating economic inequality.
As a global brand with a strong legacy, McDonald’s has long been a symbol of affordability and accessibility. But by prioritizing profits over value, it risks undermining the very qualities that made it a household name. McDonald’s pricing strategy in 2024 has left many customers questioning their loyalty to the “golden arches.”
© Photo
Gene J. Puskar (AP), Doug Mills (AP), Evan Vucci (AP), and Natali Kuzina, WD Stock (via Shutterstock)
